Best Camping Wood Stove For Winter Hot Tenting

Last Updated on

If you’re looking for the best camping wood stove, there’s plenty to consider. With a reasonable amount of choice on the market you want to make sure that your hard-earned cash is going to be spent on a worthy product.

With that in mind, we have put together this brief buyers guide for you plus we reveal our feedback regarding five camping wood stoves that we have tested ourselves. We hope that you will find this information useful so that you can enhance your own camping experience.

What is a camping wood stove?

Just so we’re clear we’re talking about wood stoves that go in your tent and incorporate a stove pipe that goes through a tent jacket in the ceiling or side of your tent. This type of stove gives you the ability to boil water, warm your tent, dry your clothes and enable you to cook. They’re perfect for hunters, prospectors, outfitters and families on longer camps.

What are the benefits of choosing a wood-burning stove?

There are many different types of stoves out there for camping purposes, so why consider a wood stove? One of the main reasons is because of the fact that fuel can often be located in the surrounding area. So long as the location is suitable, you are not going to need to carry huge amounts of carbon based fuel.

Pine cones, sticks, twigs, or even pre-made pellets all make great fuel. These you can often be sourced while you are camping. In fact, if the weather is good it can be something fun for everyone to get involved in. This also makes it cheaper and more convenient for you in terms of packing and traveling.

A lot of the wood burning stoves out there are designed to be smokeless too, which is good news for the person who has the task of cooking. They’re simple, practical, and a good alternative to the propane based fuel stoves out there. It’s not hard to see why more and more people are searching for the best camping wood stove for winter hot tenting.

What should you consider when looking for a wood stove?

You can narrow your search by considering the following features;

  • Size, weight, and portability – Do you need a portable option? Perhaps it needs to break down and store within itself? Or maybe you’re quite happy to lug it about in your vehicle as required.
  • Ease of set-up and use – There is nothing more frustrating than buying something that is meant to make your camping experience easier, yet all it does is give you stress. You don’t want to spend all of your time camping struggling with your new stove!
  • Added features – Are there any useful added features? Some wood stoves come with handy extras like, drying racks or alcohol trays. You might also get a storage bag for your stove too as part of the purchase. Consider what’s part of the package.
  • Durability – Anything that you purchase for camping purposes needs to be durable. After all, it is going to need to withstand being packed, unpacked and put to use in potentially challenging conditions. You’ll want to make sure that it lasts for a period that reflects the price too. The word flimsy and camping simply do not go together.
  • Efficiency – How thermally efficient is the stove? Does it eat wood at a rate of knots or is the unit nicely sealed with good control over airflow? No one wants to be feeding the stove all night to keep warm.
  • Cooking performance – Does the product cook your food efficiently? How long will it take for you to have hot water?
  • Smoke – Is the stove smoke-free internally?

The wood-burning camping stoves that we have tried!

We have tested out the following camping wood stoves using our Danchel Bell Tent with stove jacket as the guinea pig.

1. Winnerwell Woodlander Large Tent Stove – The best camping wood stove excelling in all areas

Firstly, we have the Winnerwell Woodlander, which is cited by the manufacturer as a portable wood-burning stove that is good for cooking and heating in small recreational spaces. Just like our test tent.

You get what you pay for with this stove, which is good news because it is relatively expensive. However, if you are looking to spend your money on a quality stove that is reliable and built really well, it is certainly a top contender.

Precise smooth control resulting in longer burns

The main thing we appreciated about this stove is how easy it is to control. The adjustment for the damper and the air vent are really smooth and once you’ve got them right there is very little smoke. This is unlike the Shasta and SHTFandGo stoves we reviewed.

Once the stove is up to temperature you can almost fully close the flue and damper to get a burn from a few small logs that will last hours. Among these 5 stoves this is the product that will give you the best chance of warmth through the night.

Once the stove had peaked in terms of temperature and then settled down it cooked our bacon perfectly. We don’t want it too hot that it burns food or not hot enough so you’re waiting around. The tent was also warmed in the process.

In terms of burn control only adding a proper seal/gasket to the door would improve the Winnerwell Woodlander.

As with any stove we would recommend undertaking the first burn outside before you use the stove within a tent and certainly before cooking any food on it.

Extremely well made

The Winnerwell Woodlander really does feel like a classy model and it’s easy to set up. A little bit ahead of the rest by virtue of the fact that it goes together simply. It has legs that properly tighten with spring loading that help the unit to accommodate rough ground. They also fold flat underneath the stove body.

Our only real criticism is that we would prefer something more secure than the eyelets that are used to tie-down the spark arrestor. Considering the stove itself is so durable and strong, it’s a bit of a let-down that the eyelets are quite flimsy. They look like they could break in high winds though it would be relatively easy to repair them.

Pros

  • Great burn time thanks to precise control
  • Durable and well made
  • Easy to set up with sprung legs
  • Low smoke even on first burn
  • Useful viewing window
  • Stainless steel construction
  • Useful racks for keeping food warm or drying clothes

Cons

  • Flimsy eyelets that tie down the spark arrestor
  • One of the higher-priced models

Overall the Winnerwell is one of the best portable wood-burning stoves we have come across at this price. The unit is extremely well made with mainly stainless steel components. The pack also includes everything you need to get hot tenting.

The main advantage of this product over the others though are the excellent controls. The damper, flue and viewing window all combine so that you can get the most from the fuel offered to the stove.

Put simply if you can afford it then go and get one. Winnerwell also offer the same unit in different sizes.

 

2. Guide Gear Outdoor Wood Stove

We were certainly impressed with this Guide Gear stove. It really does tick all of the boxes for the low price. The first thing we noticed is just how well constructed this stove is. All of the piping and stove body is steel.

Good burn efficiency

Following an initial burn you’re good to go and use it for camping. The burn efficiency is pretty impressive making it a great stove for camping.You could probably use it for many other purposes too because it is so durable and effective.

If you’re looking for an old school stove that does exactly what it claims to do, this is the solution for you. The stove could easily heat a well-built 350 square foot cabin. However, we must point out that the stove is not specifically designed for indoor installation; we’re purely stating this to give you an understanding of the level of heat that it gives off.

Short legs

The legs on the stove are not very tall, so you may want to think about different ways to raise the stove off the ground if this is going to be an issue for you. The door latch is also quite small. However, as you can probably tell, we’re really nitpicking here as overall, it’s great.

The stove pipe is probably the most impressive component. A lot of the stoves out there come with thin, walled, tin pipes, which is frustrating. You don’t get that here. The pipe is constructed into five sections, which are really easy to assemble.

Pros

  • Cheap heat
  • Good burn efficiency
  • All parts included

Cons

  • Short stove legs
  • Small door latch

Cheap and heat are not two words we’re fond of using together. After all, cheap can often indicate poor quality, and you can’t afford to take a chance on poor quality when it comes to your safety! However, with the Guide Gear you really do get fantastic, cheap heat. For the price, we don’t think you can beat it.

Guide Gear Outdoor Wood Stove
List Price: $119.99
Price: $119.99
You Save: N/A

 

3. Camp Chef Alpine Heavy Duty Cylinder Stove – Great features and cooking surface but fittings could be more refined

Next, we have the Camp Chef. Well, where to begin. This stove kit definitely had us interested from the start with it’s inclusion of all the main components.

Not the most portable design

Let’s begin by getting the negatives out the way. Firstly the stove could be considered quite weighty but only if you’re looking for portability. It is not designed for hiking or to go from place-to-place. If that’s the sort of adventure you’re going to be going on, this is probably not going to be the choice for you.

If you are happy with a stove that will remain in the same spot during your long fishing or hunting trip, providing you with the heat you need, the Camp Chef is potentially a good option.

Damper control could be better

The Camp Chef doesn’t quite have the refined control of the Winnerwell. There is a gap around the door and the air vents were also loose on our test model. This means you can’t slow the burn down as much as with the Winnerwell, so you’ll use fuel quicker. Someone will need to be up in the night to keep this thing going.

The Camp Chef does cook well though despite the basic control. The large surface area of the stove means you can have a couple of pans going at once. The racks either side will also help keep food warm – that or help you dry gloves and socks!

On another positive note the legs of the stove are sturdy and they are adjustable too, which gives you sturdiness even when you are on uneven ground. This is despite the leg welds being a little crooked. The Camp Chef is comparable to the Winnerwell in this respect and this an advantage over the cheaper Guide Gear product.

Offers good value for money

Another thing that we really liked about this product is that it comes with everything you need to get going. No need for any separate purchases. This represents real value for money at almost half the price of the Winnerwell.

You will receive a five-piece nesting pipe, as well as accessory shelves, a spark arrestor, internal log grate, and a dampener, meaning you have everything that you require!

Pros

  • Sturdy and durable construction with good base materials
  • Good amount of surface area for cooking
  • Accessories included
  • Fire grate in bottom to prevent overheating of base
  • Will accept a standard wood stove water heater
  • Good value for money

Cons

  • Would benefit from a door gasket
  • Can burn wood a little too quickly
  • Spark arrestor can let moisture in
  • Non standard 5″ pipe
  • Welding on legs a little crooked

Given the price the Camp Chef Alpine is a great product. Compared with the Winnerwell it does fall short but you’ll save a ton on the initial purchase.

The Camp Chef is well built and heats up quickly. As long as you take it in turns to add more fuel regularly you’ll have heat on tap. A simple upgrade that might reduce the rate at which you go through fuel would be to add a gasket to the door. Still this is a good product for the price.

 

4. SHTFandGo Bullet Proof Gravity Feed Rocket Stove & Tent Heater

This SHTFandGO Bullet Proof Steel Stove and Tent Heater is certainly durable. That’s one thing we knew we were going to get before trying out the product. After all, with a material like steel and a promise like bulletproof, we knew that this stove was really going to deliver on the strength and longevity front. It did not disappoint.

Bombproof construction

We’re sure that this stove is pretty much indestructible, although we didn’t try any tests of the sort!

There was a lot we liked about this stove. The visual fire really appealed, as it created a cozy feeling. It warmed the area well, giving off a good amount of heat so that we could still enjoy the cool evening. Cooking on the stove was a real joy as well.

A little rough around the edges

However this stove does need a little bit of tweaking around the edges. Specifically, it can be a bit difficult to feed the wood into the burn pot area because of the rough edges. We had to keep forcefully pushing the wood inside of the burner.

Furthermore the SHTFandGO does produce a lot of smoke even after the initial burn. Much more than the Winnerwell Woodlander for example. For this reason alone we’d be tempted to look elsewhere if you plan on putting it inside your bell tent for example.

Pros

  • Strong and durable
  • Good for cooking

Cons

  • Difficult to feed the wood into the burn pot
  • A lot of smoke

 

5. Shasta Military Style Portable Camping Wood Stove

The final wood burning stove that we have got on the list is the Shasta Vent Portable, Camping Wood Stove. Described as a ‘military’ style stove, we were very excited to try this product and put it through its paves.

With folding legs, this stove is pretty easy to construct.

Doesn’t hold a lot of fuel

In terms of fuel efficiency, we noticed that the stove was very quick to heat up and very quick to cool down. This is obviously good in terms of fuel efficiency. However, because it does not hold a lot of fuel, you are going to have to keep adding fuel to keep it running. You’re not going to be able to fill the stove and get through the night without replenishing the supply of fuel.

Some control over burn rate

This stove does have the ability to open the door slightly for air intake if you are looking to control the burn rate, although this is only by a small amount. We used seasoned hardwood and managed to get a few hours of burn time out of the stove.

Fully featured

In terms of accessories and add-ons, this stove came with a vent damper, a spark arrestor cap, and more than five feet of pipe. It would be better if a greater amount of pipe was included, as this would draft the stove better, but compared to the others on test this is a plus point. The pipe was very easy to disassemble and clean.

Only the Camp Chef model came with a more comprehensive selection of add-ons, but the extras included were welcomed.

This sort of stove would be suitable for use with any suitable hot tent. Of course, as with the others, you’ll need to vent the stove outside of the tent via a roof jack.

Very smokey

On the subject of smoke, there was quite a lot of it! Drafting is also a bit of an issue on this product, which is a shame.

Pros

  • Suitable for different tents
  • Portable and easy to transport

Cons

  • Short burn time
  • A considerable amount of smoke

One of our favorite things about this tent stove is just how convenient it is. In terms of portability, we cannot complain. It packs down perfectly and everything is nestled inside. There is also a handle on the side, so that it can be carried with ease. You can take it hiking, which you can’t do with the Camp Chef model.

Overall for a small tent, it’s a reasonable and cheap, convenient choice. We wouldn’t call it military-grade, though!

 

So which is the best camping wood stove?

It’s quite clear to see that there was one product that we loved; the Winnerwell Woodlander Stove. Yes, there is a small amount of room for improvement, but overall, this wood stove has everything you need. It is very efficient, easy to control and the burn time is great. Plus, with virtually no smoke, it manages to achieve what a lot of the other stoves promised but were unable to.

Yes, it may be a little bit more expensive than some of the others. However, we believe it is worth the extra expense because it is such a good product. When you compare this with the other stoves you can see where the extra cost goes because the others were all lacking in critical areas.

The runner up

In second place, we have Camp Chef’s Alpine Stove. This is one of the more affordable options, including everything you need without cutting corners.

It does tick all of the boxes but it just misses out on the top spot because it doesn’t offer the portability of the Winnerwell. Overall, we feel that the Winnerwell Woodlander is simply a classier model, excelling in all of the key elements that bit more. However, we certainly would not object to taking the Camp Chef Alpine Stove camping with us!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*